Mas pior foi que ao meu lado estava um casal em que o homem (estava na coxia) se levantou a meio do primeiro acto para atender o telemóvel, saindo e entrando pouco depois de forma ruidosa dado que o solo é e madeira. E a mulher passou toda a récita a bater com o tacão do sapato no chão acompanhando o que considerava ser o ritmo da música. Horrível!
Linda di Chamounix, Liceu, Barcelona, January 2012
Linda di Chamounix is a late semiseria opera by Gaetano Donizetti, with libretto by Gaetano Rossi.
The opera tells the story of the romance of Linda, daughter of two modest peasants of Chamounix in the French Alps, Antonio and Maddalena, with Carlo (false identity of Viscount Sirval) who is the nephew of the Marquis de Boisfleury who also wishes Linda. Linda is sent to
It is an opera of inferior quality when compared with many others of Donizetti and has a very dull 3rd act but, with a cast of exceptional quality, as in this case, it becomes a memorable performance .
The staging by Emilio Sagi is interesting and effective, though not bring anything new. The first act in
Marco Armiliato conducted in a somewhat irregular way the Orchestra of the Liceu. Sometimes it sounded too loud, overshadowing all the singers, sometimes at a slow pace and occasionally mismatched singers, including the Choir that also performed well.
What was truly amazing was the quality of singers offered by the Liceu:
Linda was interpreted by German soprano Diana Damrau. I do not have words to describe the stunning vocal and artistic quality of the singer. Although young, Damrau's voice has grown in recent years and reached a rarely heard splendor. She is truly fabulous in all registers, the coloratura is of a masterful quality, the potency great and the top notes ware stratospheric and always tuned. If in the aria O luce di quest’anima (1st act) she was excellent, in the mad scene (end of the 2nd act) where she used her vocal pyrotechnics as very few can achieve, she finished with a natural top E, as Alberto Velez Grilo from the blog Outras Escritas told me. The role of Linda is very long and vocally demanding. On stage Damrau is very credible and as I mentioned, in the mad scene at the end of the 2nd act, she was overwhelming. She had a long and sound ovation that was fully deserved. Sensational!
Juan Diego Flórez, Peruvian tenor, was Carlo. As I wrote in this blog several times, he is one of my favorite singers and, once again, he was at his best. Currently he has no rival in this repertoire. The voice is also more powerful but maintains the unsurpassed quality. The tone is unmistakable, the legato is smooth and fabulous, the coloratura is luxurious and top notes are unique in quality and extent. The role is not extensive but in the 2nd act aria Se tanto in ira agli uomini he showed all his qualities and also received a loud and lengthy ovation. His figure gives him credibility on stage, although he is not a gifted actor as he is a singer. Florez, despite his youth, has already reached a level of acceptance that wherever he sings, he is adored by the public, and that was the case in
Marques de Boisfleury was the Italian bass-baritone Bruno de Simone. He sang well, the voice is respectable and, in what the character allows it, he was OK.
Spanish bass Simón Orfila was a stupendous Perfecte! It was by far the best interpretation that I hear from him. The voice revealed an extraordinary power, and in the low register he was superb. His good figure and agility on stage completed his terrific performance. Excellent!
Also fantastic was another Spanish singer, mezzo Silvia Tro Santafe who played Pierotti. Another powerful voice, in tune, of great beauty and with a low register of a quality rarely heard. On stage she was remarkable. The role is sufficiently long and diverse to allow the singer a brilliant and unforgettable performance.
Italian baritone Pietro Spagnoli was a “gray” Antonio. The voice was not fantastic, especially when compared with the others. he was often drowned out by the orchestra and he was unable to transmit emotion.
Maria Jose Suarez, Spanish soprano, sang the very short role of Maddalena with some tendency to stridency.
A final word about the public. I have already praised several times the demanding and the behaviour of the public of
But worse was that by my side there was an unforgettable couple. The man (he was in the wings) got up and leave halfway through the first act to answer the mobile phone, and shortly after came back making a lot of noise as the soil is and wood. The woman spent all the performance hitting with the heel of the shoe on the floor at what was for her the rhythm of the music. Horrible!
But overall, despite the poor quality of the opera and the regrettable behaviour of the public, the exceptional soloists supplanted everything else.
Meu caro FanaticoUmResponderEliminar
Em primeiro lugar, obrigado pela referência ao Outras Escritas. Esta era uma das óperas a que eu tinha planeado assistir nesta temporada. Flórez e Damrau, são praticamente imbatíveis. Depois Sílvia Tro Santafé que já ouvi em La Donna del Lago em Lisboa e L'italiana in Algeri em Madrid e que considero um dos melhores mezzos da actualidade e cujo reconhecimento ainda não lhe foi devidamente feito, na minha opinião.
Obrigado pelo seu testemunho.
Damrau é sempre brutal! Já não a oiço ao vivo há algum tempo...ResponderEliminar
Quanto ao Florez espero ser nesta nova temporada a minha estreia ao vivo :)
Acha que este publico de Barcelona nesta récita terá feito um estágio com o público da Gulbenkian :)...
Também ouvi Silvia Tro Santafè em Lisboa e gostei muito. Ia à procura do Flórez, que foi substituído por Rockwell Blake...ResponderEliminar
Diana Damrau? Também gostaria de a ouver ao vivo.
Foi uma récita extraordinária, com cantores excelentes e em grande forma. A prova de que, com um elenco deste calibre, se consegue fazer de uma ópera desinteressante, um espectáculo inesquecível.
Damrau nunca falha nem nunca desilude, é verdade. Nunca ter ouvido o Flórez ao vivo é uma falha gravíssima no seu curriculo. Como sabe é um cantor que muito admiro há anos e que está no apogeu das suas capacidades vocais.
Também eu fui a esse espectáculo para rever o Flórez em Lisboa (La Donna del Lago de Rossini, certo?), no ano a seguir a um concerto fabuloso que deu no São Carlos. Infelizmente foi substituído à última hora.
não canso de repetir que 'ouvi' a sua crônica. Excepcional!
Espero que tenha gostado do Brasil. Embora Foz do Iguaçu seja diferente do Rio. O Brasil é um 'continente' com a mesma língua, mas com imensa diversidade física e cultural,
Um grande abraço
Re.Florez I totally agree with you. He is also one of my favorites. Coming October he will perform in 'La Fille du régiment' at the Bastille. Even though I don't like this house, I'm planning to visit it.ResponderEliminar
many thanks to you for the interesting review.
II have seen him life in "La Fulle du régiment" 3 times. He is fabulous. Do not miss the performance, although I completely agree with you - The Bastille is too big to be an efficient opera house.
Thanks a lot ,my friends for this high, interesting revieuw!ResponderEliminar